7 Best Ice Cream Shops in Chicago

Chicago, renowned for its culinary diversity, offers a delightful array of ice cream shops that cater to every palate. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or adventurous blends, the city has something to tantalize your taste buds. Our guide, ‘7 Best Ice Cream Shops in Chicago’, will lead you through a curated selection of the finest spots to enjoy this beloved treat.

When exploring the bustling streets of Chicago in search of the perfect scoop, consider these essential services and aspects:

Flavor Variety: From traditional vanilla to exotic matcha, a wide range of flavors enhances the ice cream experience.
Custom Creations: Personalized sundaes and made-to-order ice cream sandwiches are a hit.
Dietary Options: Many shops offer vegan, dairy-free, and gluten-free alternatives.
Local Ingredients: Emphasis on locally sourced and organic ingredients for quality and freshness.
Seasonal Specials: Limited-time flavors that celebrate the seasons or local events.
Price Range: Options for every budget, with prices typically ranging from $3 to $10 per serving.
Ambiance and Design: A welcoming atmosphere with unique decor enhances the enjoyment.
Catering and Events: Some shops offer catering services for parties and special events.

Get ready to indulge in some of the most delightful ice cream experiences Chicago has to offer. Dive into our full guide to discover your next favorite spot!

1. Margie's Candies
2. Legend Tasty House
3. Shawn Michelle's Homemade Ice Cream

4. La Michoacana Premium
5. Lickity Split Frozen Custard & Sweets
6. Sugar Shack
7. Cone Gourmet Ice Cream

Number of companies

11145

Verified reviews

4,57

Average rating

(773)3841035

1. Margie's Candies

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

1960 N Western Ave, 60647.0, Chicago

Ice cream shop

Why we chose them

Margie’s Candies, a beloved old-fashioned ice cream parlor, has been a cherished Chicago landmark for over a century. Known for its exquisite homemade candies and ice creams, the company offers a delightful menu featuring 50 different ice cream sundaes and hand-dipped treats. Each product is crafted with all-natural flavors and free from artificial preservatives, ensuring a high-quality experience that has been passed down through generations.

With locations in Bucktown and Ravenswood, this iconic establishment is celebrated as the best ice cream parlor in the city. Visitors can indulge in popular choices like the Turtle Sundae and Banana Split, making it a go-to destination for families and individuals alike. The parlor also keeps patrons engaged with events, promotions, and updates, emphasizing its commitment to community and tradition.

(312)2258869

2. Legend Tasty House

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

2242 S Wentworth Ave, 60616.0, Chicago

Ice cream shop

Why we chose them

Legend Tasty House offers a vibrant and immersive experience with its unique Thai-style rolled ice cream. Situated in the heart of Old Chinatown, this ice cream shop brings the authentic flavors and tastes of Thailand straight to Chicago. With a focus on fresh ingredients, each ice cream creation is crafted right in front of the customers, adding an element of excitement and anticipation to every visit. The dynamic setup and interactive preparation process make it a standout destination for ice cream enthusiasts looking for something different.

This establishment invites patrons to indulge in a pleasurable experience with its extensive menu, available both in-store and online for convenience. The shop’s engaging atmosphere and commitment to quality are reflected in the carefully curated promotions and visually appealing presentations. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, the unique offerings and vibrant energy make it a must-visit spot for anyone seeking a delightful and memorable treat.

(773)6754032

3. Shawn Michelle's Homemade Ice Cream

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

46 E 47th St, 60653.0, Chicago

Ice cream shop

Why we chose them

Shawn Michelle’s Homemade Ice Cream Bronzeville is a charming ice cream shop that offers a delightful blend of nostalgia and innovation. Nestled in a low-key nook, this establishment is renowned for its specialty ice cream crafted from the finest ingredients. The philosophy here is simple yet profound: “Milk. Cream. Sugar. Flavor. Love!” This dedication to quality ensures that each scoop transports customers back to cherished memories of homemade desserts. The shop features a variety of unique flavors that excite the palate, such as Caribbean rum with raisins and honey with cinnamon graham crackers, making it a perfect spot for families to enjoy delightful treats together.

At this beloved ice cream shop, the emphasis is on creating new memories while honoring the old-fashioned goodness of traditional recipes. From “Nostalgic Old School” favorites to inventive blends like “My Momma’s Famous Slap Yo Son” Banana Pudding Ice Cream, each offering is a testament to their commitment to excellence. By choosing only the highest quality ingredients, the shop ensures that every visit is a memorable experience. Whether you’re indulging in the “Worlds Best” Cookies and Cream or exploring other enticing flavors, this establishment promises a sweet journey back down memory lane.

(312)2269600

4. La Michoacana Premium

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

1855 S Blue Island Ave, 60608.0, Chicago

Ice cream shop

Why we chose them

La Michoacana Premium is a beloved ice cream shop that has been delighting taste buds since 1950. Known for its rich tradition and commitment to quality, the company offers a delectable range of flavors that promise to bring the best to your palate. With a strong emphasis on preserving the authentic taste of traditional ice cream, the shop has become a cherished part of the community, providing both locals and visitors with a memorable dessert experience. Their menu is crafted to satisfy diverse preferences, ensuring everyone finds something they love.

Beyond their in-store offerings, the company also provides an ice cream truck service, bringing their signature flavors to various events and celebrations. This mobile option allows customers to enjoy their favorite treats in a unique and convenient way. Additionally, the shop offers discounts and online ordering for a seamless customer experience. Their dedication to quality and tradition makes them a standout choice for those seeking a genuine ice cream indulgence. If it’s not premium, it’s not a Michoacana, ensuring a commitment to excellence in every scoop.

(773)2740830

5. Lickity Split Frozen Custard & Sweets

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

6056 N Broadway, 60660.0, Chicago

Ice cream shop
Bakery
Candy store
Dessert shop

Why we chose them

Lickity Split Frozen Custard & Sweets LLC. is a vintage-style parlor renowned for its delightful array of sweet treats. Offering services as an ice cream shop, bakery, candy store, and dessert shop, this charming locale is a must-visit for dessert enthusiasts in Chicago. The parlor is celebrated for its unique offerings like the featured Pumpkin Pie Concrete, which blends pumpkin custard with a slice of pumpkin pie, topped with whipped cream and cinnamon. Patrons can indulge in a variety of custard flavors including pumpkin, chocolate, and vanilla, alongside a selection of pastries sourced from local bakers.

Not only does the parlor boast a full espresso bar serving Metropolis Coffee, but it also offers an expanded inventory of retro candy and handmade chocolates. The ever-changing candy selection ensures a fresh experience with every visit. With two convenient locations, both providing walk-in, take-out, and delivery services, the parlor caters to diverse preferences and schedules. Delivery is made easy through partnerships with GrubHub and PostMates, ensuring customers can enjoy their favorite treats from the comfort of home.

(312)3396002

6. Sugar Shack

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

630 W 26th St, 60616.0, Chicago

Ice cream shop

Why we chose them

Sugar Shack has been a beloved summertime destination in Bridgeport, Chicago since 2006. Known for its famous Funnel Cake Sundaes, this family-owned ice cream shop is a cornerstone of the community, drawing in locals and visitors alike with its mouthwatering desserts. The shop offers a delightful array of 12 hand-scooped ice cream flavors, soft serve options, and over 30 toppings, encouraging customers to craft their own unique treats. Owner Nikki Panatera emphasizes the family-friendly atmosphere and takes pride in fostering a supportive environment for her young staff, creating a warm and inviting experience for all who visit.

Beyond its signature sundaes, the shop features homemade Italian ice, creamy milkshakes, and seasonal specialties like Patriotic Parfaits and Caramel Apple Sundaes. Each funnel cake is fried fresh to order, allowing patrons to indulge in a crispy, light, and perfectly sweet base topped with their choice of delicious combinations. With a focus on quality and creativity, Sugar Shack has earned a reputation for delivering unforgettable treats, making it a must-visit spot for anyone craving something sweet and extraordinary in Chicago.

(312)6665111

7. Cone Gourmet Ice Cream

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

1047 W Madison St, 60607.0, Chicago

Ice cream shop

Why we chose them

Cone Gourmet Ice Cream brings a unique blend of old-school charm and Irish flair to the vibrant city of Chicago. Since opening its doors in 2013, this family-owned ice cream parlor has been delighting customers with its rich and creamy flavors. Owner Sean McGuire, originally from Belmullet, County Mayo in Ireland, infuses his heritage into the shop, creating an inviting atmosphere where customers feel like part of the family. The parlor is renowned for its exceptional quality and friendly service, making it a beloved spot for both locals and visitors.

The shop offers a diverse selection of intriguing flavors, such as green apple, butter pecan, Baileys Irish crème, and even bacon ice cream, ensuring a delightful treat for every palate. Customers rave about the friendly staff and the fun experience of discovering new flavors, making each visit memorable. The $2 kiddie cone option is a hit among families, providing the perfect portion for little ones. Cone Gourmet Ice Cream stands out as a must-visit destination in Chicago’s West Loop, celebrated for its delicious offerings and warm hospitality.

FAQs

What types of ice cream flavors can I expect to find in Chicago's shops?

Chicago's ice cream shops offer a wide range of flavors, from classic options like vanilla and chocolate to exotic choices like matcha and lavender. Many shops also feature seasonal specials and unique blends to keep things exciting.

Are there vegan or dairy-free ice cream options available in Chicago?

Yes, many ice cream shops in Chicago offer vegan and dairy-free alternatives to accommodate different dietary preferences. These options often include sorbets, coconut milk-based ice creams, and almond milk varieties.

What is the average price range for ice cream in Chicago?

The average price for a serving of ice cream in Chicago ranges from €2.50 to €8.50, depending on the size and complexity of the order. Custom creations and specialty items may be priced higher.

How can I choose a good ice cream shop in Chicago?

Consider factors such as flavor variety, quality of ingredients, ambiance, and customer reviews. Visiting shops that emphasize locally sourced and organic ingredients can also enhance your experience.

Do ice cream shops in Chicago offer catering services for events?

Yes, some ice cream shops in Chicago provide catering services for parties and special events, offering a range of options from ice cream carts to custom sundae bars.

What should I consider when ordering a custom ice cream creation?

Think about your flavor preferences, any dietary restrictions, and the type of dessert you want, such as sundaes or ice cream sandwiches. Discuss your ideas with the shop to create a personalized treat.

Are there any ice cream shops in Chicago that focus on using local ingredients?

Many ice cream shops in Chicago prioritize using locally sourced and organic ingredients to ensure freshness and support local farmers. This focus often enhances the quality and flavor of their offerings.

Do ice cream shops in Chicago offer seasonal or limited-time flavors?

Yes, many shops create seasonal or limited-time flavors that reflect local events or seasonal ingredients. These special offerings provide a unique tasting experience and are worth trying when available.