The 7 Best Italian Restaurants in Chicago

Chicago is a city renowned for its diverse culinary scene, and when it comes to Italian cuisine, it offers a rich tapestry of flavors and experiences. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty lasagna, or a sophisticated osso buco, the 7 best Italian restaurants in Chicago deliver exceptional dishes that transport diners straight to Italy. This guide highlights the top spots where the authenticity and passion of Italian cooking come alive.

When choosing the perfect Italian restaurant, consider the following services and aspects:

Authenticity of ingredients and recipes
Range of menu options including vegetarian and gluten-free
Wine selection featuring Italian wines
Ambiance reflecting a traditional or modern Italian setting
Price range from affordable options to fine dining, with meals typically ranging from $15 to $50
Availability of takeout and delivery services
Options for private dining and special events
Customer reviews and ratings

Discover the culinary gems that make Chicago a haven for lovers of Italian cuisine, where each restaurant offers a unique taste and experience.

1. Gino's East
2. The Village
3. Rpm Italian

4. Gibsons Italia
5. La Villa Restaurant Lounge and Banquets
6. Calo Ristorante
7. Flo & Santos

Number of companies

28036

Verified reviews

4,54

Average rating

(312)2663337

1. Gino's East

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

162 E Superior St, 60611.0, Chicago

Pizza restaurant
Bar
Caterer
Italian restaurant
Lunch restaurant
Delivery Restaurant
Pizza delivery
Pizza Takeout

Why we chose them

Gino’s East has been delighting pizza lovers since 1966 with its legendary deep-dish pizzas, celebrated for their iconic cheese pulls. This family-owned and operated institution offers a variety of services, including dining in their pizza and Italian restaurants, enjoying the vibrant bar scene, and catering for special events. Whether patrons are stopping by for lunch, opting for delivery, or grabbing takeout, this beloved establishment ensures a memorable experience. With locations spanning from the Magnificent Mile in Chicago to Los Angeles and even Singapore, Gino’s East has expanded its reach while maintaining the authentic taste and quality that started it all.

Apart from their famous pizzas, the restaurant also offers a range of salads and sandwiches, catering to diverse tastes and dietary needs. They provide vegan cheese and gluten-free options, although a gluten-free deep-dish is not available at this time. Outdoor seating is offered at select locations during warmer months, enhancing the dining experience. For those unable to visit in person, Gino’s East offers nationwide shipping through Goldbelly, bringing their iconic flavors right to customers’ doorsteps. This dedication to quality and accessibility is why Gino’s East is a standout choice for inclusion in our directory.

(312)3327005

2. The Village

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

71 W Monroe St, 60603.0, Chicago

Italian restaurant
American restaurant

Why we chose them

The Village, a cornerstone of Chicago’s culinary scene since 1927, is celebrated for its rich history and authentic dining experience. As Chicago’s oldest Italian restaurant, it offers a unique blend of Italian and American cuisine, appealing to a wide range of palates. This fourth-generation family-owned establishment brings classic Italian-American dishes to life, from the beloved Chicken Parmigiana to Chicago Tavern-Style Pizza and fresh-made pasta. Known for its award-winning wine cellar and warm hospitality, it provides a memorable dining experience for every occasion, whether it’s a casual meal or a special event.

Renowned for hosting a variety of events, The Village regularly organizes special dinners, wine and liquor tastings, and art shows. Its historic charm adds a unique touch to celebrations like birthdays, anniversaries, and corporate gatherings. While the building’s historic nature means accessibility is limited to stairs, the restaurant remains dedicated to providing exceptional service and unforgettable memories. Patrons can stay updated on upcoming happenings and book reservations through their website, ensuring they never miss out on the vibrant offerings of this iconic Chicago destination.

(312)2221888

3. Rpm Italian

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

52 W Illinois St, 60654.0, Chicago

Italian restaurant
Event venue
Restaurant

Why we chose them

RPM Italian, located in Chicago’s vibrant River North neighborhood, offers a modern twist on traditional Italian fare. With a sleek and contemporary setting, the restaurant is known for its innovative menu that features dishes meant to be shared. This establishment is a standout choice in our directory due to its unique partnership between RJ, Jerrod, and Molly Melman of Lettuce Entertain You Enterprises and celebrity couple Giuliana & Bill Rancic. As the first collaboration among these partners, RPM Italian brings a fresh and dynamic approach to Italian dining, complemented by daily housemade pastas and a diverse selection of antipasti and entrees.

In addition to its enticing culinary offerings, RPM Italian serves as a premier event venue, providing an elegant space for private parties and special occasions. The restaurant’s dedication to quality extends beyond its menu, with an impressive wine list that showcases a variety of Italian and American selections. As the sister restaurant to RPM Steak and RPM Seafood, it embodies the same commitment to excellence and innovation. This makes RPM Italian a must-visit destination for those seeking a refined yet approachable dining experience in the heart of Chicago.

(312)4141100

4. Gibsons Italia

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

233 N Canal St, 60606.0, Chicago

Italian restaurant
Seafood restaurant
Steak house

Why we chose them

Gibsons Italia is a swanky, traditional Italian steakhouse renowned for its exceptional fusion of Italian flavors and top-tier steakhouse excellence. Nestled in Chicago, the restaurant elevates dining with chef-driven tastes that transform the familiar into the extraordinary. Patrons are treated to an elegant atmosphere, where the culinary expertise of Italy meets the superior quality of Gibsons Steakhouse. This unique blend ensures a memorable dining experience, making it a standout choice for those seeking both authenticity and innovation in their meals.

Offering a diverse array of services, including Italian and seafood cuisine alongside its signature steaks, the restaurant caters to a variety of palates. Beautiful private dining spaces are available, enhancing its appeal for special occasions or intimate gatherings. The establishment’s commitment to relentless pursuit of excellence is reflected in its customer-centric services, such as reservations and valet availability. As part of the esteemed Gibsons Restaurant Group, it shares a legacy of quality and sophistication, making it a worthy addition to our directory.

(773)2837980

5. La Villa Restaurant Lounge and Banquets

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

3638 N Pulaski Rd, 60641.0, Chicago

Italian restaurant
Delivery Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

La Villa Restaurant Lounge and Banquets has been a cherished staple in Chicago’s Old Irving Park since 1972. Under the expert guidance of owner Salvatore Canale, this homey spot seamlessly blends traditional Italian and American cuisine, making it a local favorite. Known for its famous pizza and a wide variety of dinner options, the restaurant offers a delightful culinary experience whether dining in or enjoying their convenient delivery service. The old-school charm of the dining room, coupled with a friendly staff, ensures that every visit is unforgettable, attracting generations of loyal customers.

This versatile venue offers more than just dining. It hosts events in its elegant banquet facilities, perfect for birthdays, weddings, and family reunions. Catering services are also available for those looking to entertain at home or other venues without the hassle of cooking. With a menu crafted from the freshest ingredients, La Villa promises a memorable dining experience, highlighted by seasonal specialties like pumpkin-infused dishes and homemade pasta. Its longstanding reputation and commitment to quality make it a standout choice for inclusion in our directory.

(773)2717782

6. Calo Ristorante

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

5343 N Clark St, 60640.0, Chicago

Italian restaurant
Bar
Delivery Restaurant
Pizza delivery
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Calo Ristorante, a cherished family-owned Italian eatery, has been a staple in Chicago’s historic Andersonville neighborhood since 1963. Known for its warm ambiance with vintage exposed brick walls and classic Italian-inspired art, this restaurant offers a delightful dining experience. Patrons can enjoy a diverse menu featuring authentic Italian and American dishes, including stone-fired pizzas, succulent steaks, and their “legendary” fall-off-the-bone BBQ ribs. Whether dining in or opting for delivery, Calo ensures that customers savor their favorite meals with exceptional service and a welcoming atmosphere.

The restaurant’s extensive offerings include a full bar, making it an ideal spot for casual dining or special events. With generous portion sizes and a menu that spans from traditional pastas to market-fresh seafood, Calo Ristorante caters to a variety of tastes. The establishment is well-regarded for its attentive service and the Recchia family’s commitment to providing memorable culinary experiences. Their dedication to quality and community involvement has made them a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike, contributing to Andersonville’s rich cultural and architectural tapestry.

(312)5669817

7. Flo & Santos

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

1310 S Wabash Ave, 60605.0, Chicago

Italian restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Flo & Santos offers a unique dining experience in Chicago’s South Loop, blending Italian and Polish-American flavors in a warm, inviting atmosphere. The restaurant, known for its authentic “Tavern Style” pizza, caters to a diverse palate with dishes like pierogies, kielbasa, and traditional Italian pastas. Diners can enjoy their meals in a cozy interior featuring exposed brick and red booths, or in the spacious outdoor beer garden. The venue is family-friendly, becoming more vibrant in the evenings, and is equipped with seventeen flat screens to ensure no sporting event is missed.

Under the creative culinary direction of Chef Lupe, who began her career at an upscale Italian restaurant, the menu features a delightful fusion of flavors with items like the Polish Sampler and unique creations such as the Ravirogi and Combo sandwich. The restaurant also offers delivery and takeout services through platforms like Uber Eats, Grubhub, and DoorDash, ensuring accessibility for all. With its rich heritage, inspired by the founders’ Polish and Italian roots, the establishment is a tribute to Chicago’s immigrant history, offering a distinctive taste of both cultures in every dish.

FAQs

What should I look for when choosing an Italian restaurant in Chicago?

When selecting an Italian restaurant in Chicago, consider the authenticity of ingredients and recipes, the range of menu options including vegetarian and gluten-free, the wine selection featuring Italian wines, and the ambiance reflecting a traditional or modern Italian setting.

What is the average price range for dining at an Italian restaurant in Chicago?

The average price range for meals at Italian restaurants in Chicago typically ranges from €14 to €47 ($15 to $50), depending on whether you choose affordable options or fine dining experiences.

Do Italian restaurants in Chicago offer takeout and delivery services?

Yes, many Italian restaurants in Chicago offer takeout and delivery services, allowing you to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine from the comfort of your home.

How can I find Italian restaurants that offer vegetarian or gluten-free options?

Look for restaurants that specify a diverse menu with vegetarian and gluten-free options. Checking online menus or calling the restaurant directly can also provide this information.

What kind of ambiance can I expect in Italian restaurants in Chicago?

Italian restaurants in Chicago offer a variety of ambiances, from traditional settings that evoke a classic Italian feel to modern, chic environments. The atmosphere often complements the style of cuisine offered.

Are there Italian restaurants in Chicago that provide private dining or event hosting?

Yes, many Italian restaurants in Chicago offer private dining options and can host special events. It's best to inquire directly with the restaurant to understand their capacity and services.

How important are customer reviews when choosing an Italian restaurant?

Customer reviews and ratings can provide valuable insights into the quality of food and service at an Italian restaurant. They can help you gauge the overall dining experience before you visit.

What is the wine selection like at Italian restaurants in Chicago?

Italian restaurants in Chicago often feature a robust selection of Italian wines, ranging from well-known regions like Tuscany and Piedmont to lesser-known, unique varietals. Pairing suggestions are usually available to complement your meal.